The young Immortal grimaced, still in thrall to the mental images. "No," he rasped, shaking his head, hands locked on the couch cushions to either side of him in a white-knuckled grip. "What does she know, Richie?" Vanya repeated, not giving him a chance to gather his wits, determined to break through before the wall fell back into place. "What does Tessa know!?" "I can't," he cried, eyes pleading with hers for understanding. "Yes, you can," she insisted, overriding her maternal instincts, going for blood now. His mouth opened and closed and a strangled sound came out. "Say it!" "It's. . .my. . .f-fault," he stammered, eyes impossibly blue in an otherwise colorless face. "Oh, God, she knows. . .it's my fault. I stood there and watched him shoot her. I could have stopped him!" "How, Richie? How could you have stopped a man with a gun?" "I'm immortal, I could have..." "No, Richie. You were an unarmed, frightened teenager on a dark street at night against a man with a gun. You didn't know you were an Immortal, and if you had--" "No, I--" "And if you had known," she continued, "if you had had time to jump in front of her - then what?" She answered before Richie had the chance. "Then he would have shot you first, and her second, and it wouldn't have made any difference at all." "You don't know that. I could've saved her." She reached out to him only to have him jump away, leaping to his feet to avoid her touch, overturning her vacated chair in his haste. It slammed against the wall-mounted bookcase, sending several tomes thudding to the floor. "No! No, you don't understand!" He continued moving away, oblivious to the debris, nearly tripping over it as he backed up against the desk. "A hundred Richie Ryans aren't worth one Tessa Noel! Even if I didn't know I was immortal, I should have stopped him. Done. . .something." He threw his arms wide in a pose of helplessness. "Something." "You should have attacked him? Committed suicide on the chance that this stranger might shoot, might just *possibly* kill her? Don't you see, Richie?" she tried desperately. "If we're going to play 'what ifs' then it could have been that very move that set him off. How could you have known?" She rose from her seat on the couch, moving slowly, trying to unobtrusively put herself between him and the newly-remounted scimitar. "I blew up at Mac the day he started my training, accused him of feeling guilty over Tessa, like it was his fault. But we both knew it wasn't true. We both knew who was really to blame," he said, as if she hadn't spoken. "We both knew who should have died that night." Both Immortals started when a third, angry voice cut in. "What are you talking about?" In their agitation, neither had noticed the dark form standing in the now-open doorway. "Richie, you don't believe that," Duncan said forcefully, face a thundercloud as he strode into the room, closing the distance between himself and his student. The redhead was disconcerted by the Scot's appearance for only a moment, his anger deserting him in the face of Duncan's. "C'mon, Mac, you know it's true," he said in defeat, the words finally out in the open for all to hear. "That I wished you had died in Tessa's place? No, Richie, I never felt that way." He stood an arm's length away now, regarding the young man with a mixture of concern and consternation. "Richie look at me," he ordered, waiting until the smaller Immortal complied before saying, "I never wished it had been you instead of her. How could you even think that?" Righteous indignation vied with the anger in his voice. Richie held eye contact for a brief moment as his inner demons struggled to surface again. Vanya watched, a silent observer mentally urging him on, as Richie fought a battle with himself. She felt bereft at his next words. "It doesn't matter," he droned, turning away, demons subdued for the moment. "It does matter!" Duncan raged. He swung Richie back around by one arm. . .and Vanya saw a glimmer of hope. "It does matter," Duncan repeated, standing nearly nose to nose with the younger Immortal now. "You think I would trade one life for another? That I thought so little of you that I would have wished you dead at nineteen, just to have Tessa with me?" "No! Mac...you just don't get it!" The words were hurled at him in frustration. "Then explain it to me," the Scot persisted. "Tell me what I don't understand." "You want me to say it? All right! I blew it, okay! Big time! I was supposed to protect her and I screwed up! It would have been better if we'd both died that night!" he spat out, visibly shaking. "Don't ever say that! Do you hear me, Richie?!" Duncan shouted, grabbing the younger man by his upper arms. "I don't know what I would have done after Tessa died if you hadn't been there." "She wouldn't have died at all if I hadn't been there!" "Oh, so *you* kidnapped her? *You* were the one she was being used to get to? *You* left her and a mere boy on their own afterwards, just so you could satisfy your curiosity?" He shook the young Immortal with each point. "No, Richie, you weren't to blame for any of it." "Don't you get it, Mac? You wouldn't have left her alone if I hadn't been there. You trusted me to take care of her, and I let her die!" "You think you could have stopped it? Richie, even if you had known you were immortal you can't know that for sure. What was to stop him from shooting you to death, then turning on her? It wouldn't have changed anything. Believe me. I've gone over it a hundred times in my mind, and the results are always the same." Duncan hung his head, closing his eyes a moment against the pain of old memories. He looked up again and gave the shoulders in his grip a firm squeeze. "Do you know how many people have been killed right in front of me? You're an Immortal, Richie, that doesn't mean you can save the world." "I don't want to save the world," Richie cried, all the fight going out of him in a single breath. "I just wanted to save Tessa." Whatever else he might have said came out on a strangled moan as his whole body convulsed, eyes closed tight against the emotional flood that threatened to overwhelm him. "Let it go, Rich," Duncan entreated, his voice gentle now, his strong arms all that kept the younger man from falling away from him. "She was worth crying for. Let it go." A wail of pure anguish escaped Richie's lips as the dam burst, startling in its intensity, blinding tears pouring from his eyes. He expected Duncan to push him away in disgust, but the Highlander's arms closed around him, drawing him up against a hard chest, wrapping around his back and holding him safely within their confines. The Scot felt tears soaking the front of his shirt, some of those tears his own. His were silent, Richie's seemed torn from him - the slight form encircled in Duncan's arms shook with great wrenching sobs that rose up from someplace deep within. "I'm sorry, Tessa. I'm sorry." The words were barely intelligible, but Duncan's mind echoed them, the sentiment somehow enough for now. He closed his eyes and rested his chin on the head of reddish-blond curls, holding tight as sobs continued to wrack the smaller figure, lowering them both to the carpeted floor when Richie's legs refused to hold him any longer. "Mac, I'm sorry --" "No, Rich," Duncan interrupted, "I'm sorry. We loved her, and she's gone. Your fault, my fault, nobody's fault. The guilt ends here." He continued to hold Richie in his arms as the young Immortal wound down, closing his own eyes, seeing a brief, fleeting glimpse of a smiling Tessa gazing approvingly down at them. "Thank you, Love," he mouthed, before opening his eyes again to find Vanya sitting on the floor a few feet away, legs drawn up underneath her, face wet with tears of her own, lower lip trembling even as it curved into a shaky smile. She waited until Richie had gathered his wits and pulled away from Duncan's embrace. Then both men turned to her with red-rimmed eyes. "Well done," she murmured, sniffling softly. "Well done." It was several minutes before Richie was able to pull himself to his feet and shuffle over to the couch. He looked like ten miles of bad road, but he had passed a milestone. Now the healing could begin. Duncan looked nearly as haggard, but with typical Scots' stubbornness squared his shoulders and stoically took the seat next to his subdued protege. Vanya regarded them both fondly, cataloguing their similarities. Warm-hearted, too stubborn for their own good, and loyal to a fault. That last trait had brought them a lot of happiness, and a lot of pain. She left them only long enough to prepare two cups of coffee, returning to find them still silent, looking rather like shell-shocked survivors of war. Within seconds, Richie had his face buried in his steaming cup of black coffee, but Duncan did no more than thank her and set his own cup on the table before him. He was brooding, she knew the signs. Richie's demons were out in the open now, but Duncan apparently had a few of his own to deal with. Richie interrupted her musings, lowering his cup and glancing uncertainly from one older Immortal to another, eyes coming to rest at last on the Highlander. "I wish. . ." He trailed off, then shook his head and sighed, setting his half-empty cup down on the table. "I don't know what I wish." Duncan threw him a small smile that said he understood the feeling, and Vanya gave him what she hoped was sage advice. "Richie, it may be a platitude, but it's true nonetheless; bad things happen to good people, things that aren't even remotely fair or just. Tessa lost her life at thirty-six, you lost your home and mortality at nineteen. I lost my family, Duncan his clan, and Joe his legs. The important thing is to grieve for what you've lost, and then go on. I have a feeling your Tessa wouldn't have wanted you to suffer what you have for her." "No, she wouldn't have," Duncan said, breaking his silence. "She would have known something was wrong right from the start and she would have sat him down and made him talk about what was bothering him, instead of letting it fester." He gave the young Immortal beside him an inscrutable look. "I didn't even see it." "In all fairness, Duncan, there may not have been anything *to* see. We know now that Richie suppressed his feelings, a bit too well as it turns out." "But Richie's never been very good at lying to me," the Scot argued, more with himself than her, noting the flush that rose on the young Immortal's face at this. "I should have seen it." "Richie was lying to himself, not you. And, Duncan, remember: you were having an emotional crisis of your own. You needed someone to lean on, someone who understood your pain." "You're saying I used him to get through it." Duncan's shame at the possibility was there for all to see. "No, I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying Richie offered his friendship, his strength, at a time when you needed it, and you accepted. That doesn't make you selfish, it makes you human." "Tessa wouldn't want you to suffer either, Mac," Richie cut in. "What happened to her. . .what happened to us," he corrected himself, "wasn't your fault." He gave the pair a sheepish half-grin. "I, um, I guess maybe it wasn't mine, either." The words didn't come easily. Vanya smiled approvingly at what she perceived as another breakthrough. Duncan was more demonstrative, reaching over and giving Richie's right shoulder a firm squeeze. He didn't release the hold until the young man smiled back at him, a little life returning to his features at the familiar gesture. "Now what?" Richie asked, turning to face Vanya once more. "I take it 'sayonara, see ya later' is out?" Vanya had to laugh at his attempt at levity. "A little premature, I think. Now," she said, pausing for effect, "we take things one day at a time. I'd like to continue to see you for a while. Just once a week," she added when she saw him gearing up to protest. "You've come a long way, Richie," she admitted, leaning forward to take one of his hands in both of hers, "and I truly hope we've seen the last of your night wanderings; but, if we haven't, we need to deal with that. All of us." Richie grinned, a little of his old self shining through. "Gotcha." "And, Richie, keeping things bottled up inside you is never the answer. You need to talk to. . .*someone*." Her eyes shifted to Duncan at this; an unspoken message passed between them. "For now, go home, we'll work out the details later." "Sounds like a plan," he agreed, getting to his feet, Duncan rising to stand beside him. The Scot moved toward the door and Richie went to follow, then stopped, turning back to engulf Korsikov in a hug. "Thanks," he murmured, tightening his hold fractionally before releasing her. She smiled warmly at him, one hand coming up to cup his right cheek, thumb brushing against it. "Be well," she breathed, placing a light kiss on his other cheek. She watched them both out of sight, then dropped down on the empty couch, kicked off her shoes and put her feet up on the coffee table with a sigh of pleasure, finally decompressing, a silly smile plastered to her face.